(This is the eighth installment of the popular “Up Next” series in which we highlight the top underclassmen on Long Island. Previously, we featured Dylan Weinstein, Jaxson Torres, Richie Roberts, Joe Maxwell, Dom Muccia, Fred Klauck and Logan Lamberson. Special thanks to Ken Kortright State Farm Agency for sponsoring this year’s series.)
Getting called up to varsity can be an overwhelming task for an underclassmen – let alone an 8th grader. That was not the case for Babylon’s Jake Ostertag who stepped up to the task by going 4-for-4 with 5 RBIs in the Class B Suffolk County Championship.
He took on the added responsibility in his freshman season in 2024. He compiled a strong .329 AVG/.381 OBP/.487 SLG for an .868 OPS with 25 hits, 7 doubles, 1 HR, 18 RBIs 14 R over 84 plate appearances. On the bump, he notched just 10.2 innings in relief but he struck out 13 batters with a 2.65 ERA and .135 opponent average.
His coach at Babylon HS, Michael Birnbaum, had the following to say:
Jake Ostertag shows his power with a 2-R shot to left pic.twitter.com/z0tk2mPq6n
— Axcess Baseball LI (@axcessbaseball) December 23, 2024
“Jake showed up to winter workouts as a 7th grader and stood out. He was asked to play JV in 7th grade and he joined us for playoffs in 8th grade. He stepped in as a starting OF and reliever last year. He was a middle of the order RBI guy who went 4-for-4 in the Suffolk elimination game. I told him in 7th grade that he had as much potential as he’d be willing to work for, and he’s put in the work on the field, on the mound and in the gym since and is poised to become a well recognized name on the island. Three-sport athlete who makes everyone around him better.”
Over the summer, Ostertag played for B1 Ghost EO where he continued his strong play. He compiled a .953 OPS at the plate and struck out 43 batters over 27 innings on the mound. His fastball was up to 88 MPH. He was recognized for his strong play by being named to PG All-Tournament team in all 4 tournaments he played and he was also a participant in the 2024 Northeast High School All State Games and the 2024 Axcess Home Run Derby.
He is currently the No. 4 ranked outfielder in the state for the 2027 class, according to Perfect Game. Look for him to take another step in the 2025 season.
I had a chance to speak with him and here’s what he had to say…
Was baseball always your No. 1 sport? Do you play any other sports?
Yes, baseball was always my top sport, but I also play basketball and football.
Any family members that have played college sports?
No, but everyone in my family has played sports.
Favorite players in Major League Baseball?
I have always been a huge Yankees fan and my favorite players are Mickey Mantle and Aaron Judge. Not only are/were they amazing players but they show dedication to the game and great leadership.
Do you work with any private instructors?
I go for lessons and training at B1, Five Tool Training and ProCare Athletic Performance.
What has been the most thrilling moment of your playing career?
Definitely it was last year’s Suffolk County Championship game when I went 4-for-4 with 5 RBIs. It was an exciting moment to be able to help my team win.
What are you looking to work on this offseason?
I want to keep developing my swing and gaining more power at the plate. Also, I am working on improving my mechanics and stamina on the mound, plus velocity.
What are your goals for 2025?
For school ball, my goal is to help my team go farther in the playoffs. Also, my goal is to continue to improve and train so I can help my travel team win more games, and so I can get ready to play at the college level.
What has your time been like playing for B1?
It’s been a great experience working with Coach Evan Okon and an amazing group of talented teammates. I am looking forward to another great season this summer.
Who are some individuals who have had a positive impact on you?
There are so many people that have had a positive impact on me but the ones who stand out are my mom for her constant support and my grandfather for his love of the game and for teaching me how to play. Also, I’ve had great coaches like Coach Birnbaum at Babylon who believes in my potential and encourages me every opportunity he gets. Also, I’ve been playing with the same teammates at Babylon for many years and it’s been great playing with them.
Favorite app on your phone?
Any pregame superstitions?
I have to listen to music before every game.
Favorite TV show?
Outer Banks
Favorite vacation spot?
Orlando, Florida
Best baseball trip you’ve been on?
Miami tournament last summer with B1.
